Equivalent and Inequivalent Formulations of Classical Mechanics∗
نویسنده
چکیده
In this paper, I examine whether or not the Hamiltonian and Lagrangian formulations of classical mechanics are equivalent theories. I do so by applying a standard for equivalence that was recently introduced into philosophy of science by Halvorson (2012, 2016) and Weatherall (2016a). This case study yields three general philosophical payoffs. The first is a specific plea for clarity in our discussions of equivalence, while the second and third concern how we should interpret what our physical theories say
منابع مشابه
Path integrals, density matrices, and information flow with closed timelike curves.
Two formulations of quantum mechanics, inequivalent in the presence of closed timelike curves, are studied in the context of a soluable system. It illustrates how quantum field nonlinearities lead to a breakdown of unitarity, causality, and superpo-sition using a path integral. Deutsch's density matrix approach is causal but typically destroys coherence. For each of these formulations I demonst...
متن کاملComment on “ Symplectic quantization , inequivalent quantum theories , and Heisenberg ’ s principle of uncertainty ”
In Phys. Rev. A 70, 032104 (2004), M. Montesinos and G.F. Torres del Castillo consider various symplectic structures on the classical phase space of the two-dimensional isotropic harmonic oscillator. Using Dirac’s quantization condition, the authors investigate how these alternate symplectic forms affect the quantization of the harmonic oscillator. They claim that these symplectic structures re...
متن کاملCharacterization of $2times 2$ full diversity space-time codes and inequivalent full rank spaces
In wireless communication systems, space-time codes are applied to encode data when multiple antennas are used in the receiver and transmitter. The concept of diversity is very crucial in designing space-time codes. In this paper, using the equivalent definition of full diversity space-time codes, we first characterize all real and complex $2times 2$ rate one linear dispersion space-...
متن کاملN ov 2 00 5 Not So Classical Mechanics – Unexpected Symmetries of Classical Motion
A survey of topics of recent interest in Hamiltonian and Lagrangian dynamical systems, including accessible discussions of regularization of the central force problem; inequivalent Lagrangians and Hamiltonians; constants of central force motion; a general discussion of higher-order Lagrangians and Hamiltonians with examples from Bohmian quantum mechanics, the Korteweg-de Vries equation and the ...
متن کاملar X iv : q ua nt - p h / 04 07 05 1 v 1 6 Ju l 2 00 4 Symplectic quantization , inequivalent quantum theories , and Heisenberg ’ s principle of uncertainty
We analyze the quantum dynamics of the non-relativistic two-dimensional isotropic harmonic oscillator in Heisenberg’s picture. Such a system is taken as toy model to analyze some of the various quantum theories that can be built from the application of Dirac’s quantization rule to the various symplectic structures recently reported for this classical system. It is pointed out that that these qu...
متن کامل